Monthly Archives: December 2013

Book Review of Naomi Novik’s In His Majesty’s Service (Temeraire, 1-3)

In his majesty's serviceI do occasionally read traditionally published books and Naomi Novik‘s His Majesty’s Dragon has been on my wish-list for a while now. When it came up as a group-read in one of my Goodread groups I jumped at the incentive to finally break down and buy myself a copy. I opted for the compilation, In His Majesty’s Service, containing His Majesty’s Dragon, Throne of Jade, and Black Powder War.

Description from Goodreads:
Capt. Will Laurence is serving with honor in the British Navy when his ship captures a French frigate harboring most a unusual cargo–an incalculably valuable dragon egg. When the egg hatches, Laurence unexpectedly becomes the master of the young dragon Temeraire and finds himself on an extraordinary journey that will shatter his orderly, respectable life and alter the course of his nation’s history. 

Thrust into England’s Aerial Corps, Laurence and Temeraire undergo rigorous training while staving off French forces intent on breaching British soil. But the pair has more than France to contend with when China learns that an imperial dragon intended for Napoleon–Temeraire himself– has fallen into British hands. The emperor summons the new pilot and his dragon to the Far East, a long voyage fraught with peril and intrigue. From England’s shores to China’s palaces, from the Silk Road’s outer limits to the embattled borders of Prussia and Poland, Laurence and Temeraire must defend their partnership and their country from powerful adversaries around the globe. But can they succeed against the massed forces of Bonaparte’s implacable army?

Reviews (and I’ve opted to use stars here, which I usually don’t):

His Majesty’s Dragon – 5★

Oh, I quite enjoyed this one. I found the contrast between Laurence’s prim Navy ways and life with an unpredictable dragon endearing. I enjoyed watching his growing affection for Temeraire and Temeraire’s honest open love. I did find some of it predictable and it didn’t really have much of an ending, since this is the first of a much longer series. But I’m looking forward to book two.

Throne of Jade – 3.5★

I still loved the characters and the writing and the world-building (dragon species, etc) was still astounding, but honestly I found this book a bit dull. The vast majority was comprised of traveling. While there were a few battles with [insert opponent here], most were just random encounters in the course of oceanic transport. There were very few events of actual importance to the plot. What little there was, was crowded in the last 1/4 or so of the book. Even then, Laurence’s reticence to push people/dragons for further information left the reader wanting information. Still a good book, but I didn’t enjoy it anywhere near as much as the first. 

Black Powder War – 3.5★

My review of this Black Powder War is very much the same as Throne of Jade. I adored His Majesty’s Dragon, but though I still enjoyed the writing, characters and world building of these latter books, the continued shift toward the war and politics as the primary focus of the story bored me. Plus, the fact that the books all seem to end without conclusion is annoying. I’m just not willing to dedicate myself to 5 more books in the hope of an ending. And that’s if the 8th book, published just this year, is an actual conclusion, as opposed to just the most recent book with more to come. So having reached the last page of my third 300+ book in the series I am calling it quits. 

Again, the voice of these characters is wonderful. Novik has really created very detailed draconic strata based largely on dragon size and ability. There is a lot of subtle humour and history is deftly merged with fantasy. So for the right reader this is probably a full-on five star book, as book one was for me. I, however, can’t drag my rating up that high for something I wasn’t less disappointed in.

Book Review: When We Were Married: The Long Fall, by Daniel Quentin Steele

when we were marriedPartial Description from Goodreads:
Four words ended their marriage. Four words ended his life. And changed hers forever. Four words made both of them face terrible truths about their marriage.

After those four words, nothing would ever be the same. For them. For their children.

Those words would touch the lives of cops and criminals, judges and prosecutors and defenders, the best of men and the worst of them.

The ripples cast by those four words would stretch from the warm waters of the Caribbean to the arid deserts of Mexico, from the government halls of Paris to the moonlit dunes of Matanzas south of St. Augustine.

And, when it was all over, it would finally come down to three lives. And there could be no happy ending.

Review:

**Warning this review uses language that some might find inappropriate, but I wish to give an indication of that used in the book.**

I’m really conflicted about how to rate this book because there are some aspects of it that I really like. Steele is obviously a talented writer and shows a broad and varied knowledge that makes for an interesting assortment of characters. However, there are also some aspects of if that practically curled my toes, and they aren’t easily (or at least briefly) explained.

I think this book comes across as very male. There isn’t anything wrong with that. The author, primary protagonist, and narrator are male, so it shouldn’t be at all surprising that, despite being a romance of sorts, it is also very macho. But as a female reader, there were times I felt alienated by the writing. For example, almost every description of a woman starts (and sometimes ends again) with a description of her tits, twitching ass, and whether or not she was pretty, sexy, and/or fuckable. I’m left wondering if this isn’t one of those differences between men and women situations. While I read these descriptions as fairly objectifying, I accept the possibility that a man might simply see them as descriptions of beautiful women.

While there aren’t very many actual sex scenes, at times, When We Were Married reads like Ron Jeremy’s script closet. Seriously, every cliche male sexual fantasy I could think of finds its way into these pages in some way. Well…there aren’t any fembots, but to be fair, they would have been pretty hard to fit into the plot. There’s the big-breasted nymphomaniac blond who can’t get enough, the cruise ship director, the fit barely (or not quite) legal girl crawling into your bed, the stepdaughter, the older woman, younger woman, woman in uniform, the boss’ mistress, office subordinate, friend’s wife, girlfriend’s slutty best friend (or at least friend), the divorcee, rapes, gang bangs, orgies, and more women begging to be taken in every conceivable way with no expected emotional return than I could count.

The sex scenes themselves are crude. No one in this novel makes love or even just has sex. Everyone fucks porno style. It’s coarse and raw, even when the characters are meant to be bonding on a deep emotional level. And while I have no problem with this in erotica, it felt out of place in a romance. But as I said, while people talk about sex constantly, there isn’t that much of it, so I was able to take 400 or so pages before even my rather mild inner feminist started to take umbrage. (I read an e-version, so I’m not certain of the actual page count.) Up to this point, I would have given the book an easy four stars, but the book is so long, and I was eventually worn down. Despite all of this, the book isn’t really about sex. It plays a large part in causing the turmoil that sets the scene in motion, though, and does have a legitimate place in the novel.

What I really did like about When We Were Married was the depiction of Bill as a good man who strives to do the right thing. He really breaks the mold of the powerful alpha male. He starts the book as a short, fat, balding middle-aged man. He is a king in his working life, and when the day is done, he truly enjoys going home to his wife and children. There are none of the common inferences that such dedication is a chore, and given the chance, he would gladly ease out from under the burden of fidelity. I liked this about him. I also enjoyed the message that there is always a price for doing the right thing. This is something that gets forgotten, and if you forget that there is a price for something, you also forget to appreciate the person who paid for it.

I think When We Were Married is a worthy read. It’s written for adults, and I think men will probably enjoy it more than women. But there is a good story here, and isn’t that what really matters?

Book Review: In the Blood, by Scott Skipper

in the bloodDescription from Goodreads:

George Washington Skipper was a man with secrets. He kept multiple wives in two states, spawned at least sixteen children, adopted three, spent four years in the Confederate Army, was shot twice and lived to eighty-five. Then there was one more thing and a hundred years later the family is still scandalized over it.

This fictionalized account of my ancestor’s remarkable life will probably get me struck from the Thanksgiving guest list, but those who aren’t related will be amazed and amused. Then again, are you sure we’re not related? Washington was born when John Quincy Adams was president and he died the week before the Titanic sank. During that long life he did some outrageous things. This account follows his early days in the Carolina low country, running from county to county avoiding the whipping post, through his Civil War battles, the misery of Reconstruction and his personal tragedies. In the Blood is based on fifteen years of genealogical research and punctuated with a little good clean fun.

Review:

When settling down to read a novel based on someone else’s genealogical history, there is always a niggling fear that it will be something like sitting through your neighbor’s vacation slide show, interesting to them but interminable to you. In the Blood is nothing like this. Being based on genealogical research, there is a certain amount of so-and-so beget so-and-so, who, despite being married to so-and-so beget so-and-so, but it is also a relatively fast-paced read based on a truly interesting character who also happens to find himself in gripping circumstances.

George Washington Skipper is amorous, to say the least, swept up in the Confederate spirit of the American Civil War, enlightened about the true doldrums of that (and probably every) war, discouraged by the perceived injustices of Reconstruction, and eventually the father of dozens of children by a variety of women, very few of whom he ever supported in any fashion. Ultimately, he is seen to be an even-minded good man, but he systematically wrongs woman after woman throughout the book. However, given the time in which he lived, it is, unfortunately, true that his actions may not have been as unusual as it seems to the modern reader.

For me, there was also a special thrill. As a member of ‘the 10th’ in the Confederate Army, Washington and his cohorts marched back and forth through middle Tennessee. This is home turf for me and it was really interesting to hear about the skirmishes that happened in towns I’ve lived in and around.

For those who have an interest in the Civil War and the life of the average man (ie, not the famous names of the times) In the Blood is a definite recommended read. I think there is a tendency to idealize the past, and this book provides a refreshingly realistic look at a difficult period in American History. Check it out.