I won a copy of I’m in Love With Mothman from the author, Paige Lavoie. I read it as part of my Mothman Challenge. In fact, it was part of why I created the challenge in the first place.

22-year-old Heather is suffering from an epic case of burnout.
So, just like any other young influencer, she
abandons her social platforms. Check!
gathers up her best flowy dresses. Check!
and moves to a desolate cabin. Check!
Heather imagines spending her #unplugged days traipsing through the woods and tending to her garden. However, her cottagecore fantasy is turned upside down when a wounded cryptid crashes into her roof-and her heart.
With no help from her internet followers, and the local monster-hunter growing suspicious, Heather’s quiet life in the wilderness has suddenly become a little more complicated. To make matters worse, she thinks she might be falling in love with the brooding winged man in her living room.
![]()
This was surprisingly sweet. It’s heavy on consent and acceptance (of yourself and one another). Heather is an online influencer, a vegetarian, a lover of sparkly and frilly things, who says “like” a lot. Which is a personality type that is stereotypically depicted as vacuous, not very smart, and/or mean. So, it was nice to see an author invert this and make her the lovable main character. Moth is adorable. Big and potentially scary, but also just really, really cute. The book is fairly low-angst, especially in the romance department, and it wraps up nicely before leaving a hook for the next book. Which I’d be happy to read. Though I hope the author does a little better with copy edits in book two.

Other Reviews:
Beauty’s Library: I’m in Love With Mothman



